{"text_format":"1","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":11,"sheets":["Intro","Results","Summary","Figure (ITT)","Figure (PP)","Print (ITT)","Print (PP)","Check","Print_format (PP)","Print_format (ITT)","Function Tab"],"not_rendered":{"charts":2,"images":1,"macros":1,"external_links":0,"defined_names":4,"comments":0,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Intro","index":0,"n_rows":0,"n_cols":0,"rows_kept":0,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}

{"sheet":"Results","index":1,"n_rows":18,"n_cols":85,"rows_kept":18,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,0,0,12],[0,13,0,22],[0,80,0,83],[0,23,0,40],[0,41,0,53],[0,54,0,68],[0,69,0,79]]}
["Basic information",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 1. Randomization process",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 2. Deviations from intended interventions",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 3. Mising outcome data",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 4. Measurement of the outcome",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 5. Selection of the reported result",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 6. Overall Bias"]
["Time","Unique ID","Assessor","Study ID","Reference","Experimental","Comparator","Outcome","Results","Aim","Effect of adhering to intervention?","Weight","Sources","1.1","1.2","Note for 1.1&1.2","1.3","Note for 1.3","1.0 Algorithm result","1.0 Assessor's Judgement","1.0 General note","1.0 Optional Question","1.0 Note for optional question","2.1","2.2","Note for 2.1&2.2","2.3","Note for 2.3","2.4","Note for 2.4","2.5","Note for 2.5","2.6","Note for 2.6","2.7","Note for 2.7","2.0 Algorithm result","2.0 Assessor's Judgement","2.0 General Notes","2.0 Optional Question","2.0 Note for optional question","3.1","Note for 3.1","3.2","Note for 3.2","3.3","Note for 3.3&3.4","3.4","Note for 3.4 (not use)","3.0 Algorithm result","3.0 Assessor's judgement","3.0 Gerenal notes","3.0 Optional Question","3.0 Note for optional question","4.1","Note for 4.1","4.2","Note for 4.2","4.3","Note for 4.3","4.4","Note for 4.4&4.5","4.5","Note for 4.5 (not use)","4.0 Algorithm result","4.0 Assessor's Judgement","4.0 General note","4.0 Optional Question","4.0 Note for optional question","5.1","Note for 5.1","5.2","Note for 5.2","5.3","Note for 5.3","5.0 Algorithm result","5.0 Assessor's Judgement","5.0 General note","5.0 Optional Question","5.0 Note for optional question","Algorithm's overall Judgement","Assessor's overall Judgement","6.0 General Note","6.0 Optional Question","6.0 Note for optional question"]
["2020/07/26 09.47","1_A","II",1,"Afari et al., 2019","ACT","BWL","Disinhibited eating behavior",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","Y",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"PY","N",null,"PY",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Low","Low"]
["2020/07/26 10.31","2_A","II",2,"Butryn et al., 2017","BT+EA","BT/BT+E","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","PY","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/26 11.12","3_A","II",3,"Carels et al., 2019","ABT","SH","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","PY","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PY",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PY",null,"High","High",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"High","High"]
["2020/07/26 11.47","4_A","II",4,"Forman et al., 2013","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/26 12.41","5_A","II",5,"Forman et al., 2016","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","PY","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/27 08.40","6_A","II",6,"Forman et al., 2019","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","PY","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/27 09.17","7_A","II",7,"Frayn et al., 2020","ACT","TAU","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,null,null,"High","High",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PY",null,"High","High",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"PY",null,"N",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"High","High"]
["2020/07/27 10.05","8_A","II",8,"Järvelä-Reijonen et al., 2018","ACT-Ftf/ACT-M","C","Eating behavior",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","Y",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/27 10.47","9_A","II",9,"Katterman et al., 2014","ABBI","C","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","PY","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/27 11.38","10_A","II",10,"Levin et al., 2017","ACT-M","C","Health behaviors related to weight management",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","Y",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/28 16.11","11_A","II",11,"Lillis et al., 2009","ACT","C","Weight-related stigma",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/28 16.45","12_A","II",12,"Lillis et al., 2016","ABBI","SBT","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/28 17.16","13_A","II",13,"Palmeira et al., 2017","ACT","TAU","Weight self-stigma",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/28 18.09","14_A","II",14,"Tapper et al., 2009","ACT","C","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/29 10.09","15_A","II",15,"Weineland, Arvidsson, et al., 2012","ACT-Ftf+I","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","PY","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/29 10.33","16_A","II",16,"Weineland, Hayes, et al., 2012","ACT-Ftf+I  ","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","PY","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"PN",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]

{"sheet":"Summary","index":2,"n_rows":17,"n_cols":27,"rows_kept":17,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Unique ID","Reviewer","Study ID","Reference","Experimental","Comparator","Outcome","Result","Aim","Effect of adhering to intervention?","Weight","Randomization process","Deviations from intended interventions","Mising outcome data","Measurement of the outcome","Selection of the reported result","Overall Bias",null,null,null,null,"Randomization process","Deviations from intended interventions","Missing outcome data","Measurement of the outcome","Selection of the reported result","Overall Bias"]
["1_A","II",1,"Afari et al., 2019","ACT","BWL","Disinhibited eating behavior",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Low","Low","Low","Low",null,null,null,"Assignment to intervention (the 'intention-to-treat' effect)"]
["2_A","II",2,"Butryn et al., 2017","BT+EA","BT/BT+E","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Total number of study = 0"]
["3_A","II",3,"Carels et al., 2019","ABT","SH","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Some concerns","High","Low","Some concerns","High",null,null,null,"Low risk"]
["4_A","II",4,"Forman et al., 2013","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns"]
["5_A","II",5,"Forman et al., 2016","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"High risk"]
["6_A","II",6,"Forman et al., 2019","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"]
["7_A","II",7,"Frayn et al., 2020","ACT","TAU","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","High","High","Low","Low","High",null,null,null,"Total number of study = 16"]
["8_A","II",8,"Järvelä-Reijonen et al., 2018","ACT-Ftf/ACT-M","C","Eating behavior",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Low risk",100,87.5,12.5,68.8,31.3,6.3]
["9_A","II",9,"Katterman et al., 2014","ABBI","C","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns",0,6.3,75,31.3,68.8,81.3]
["10_A","II",10,"Levin et al., 2017","ACT-M","C","Health behaviors related to weight management",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"High risk",0,6.3,12.5,0,0,12.5]
["11_A","II",11,"Lillis et al., 2009","ACT","C","Weight-related stigma",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["12_A","II",12,"Lillis et al., 2016","ABBI","SBT","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Low","Some concerns"]
["13_A","II",13,"Palmeira et al., 2017","ACT","TAU","Weight self-stigma",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Low","Some concerns"]
["14_A","II",14,"Tapper et al., 2009","ACT","C","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["15_A","II",15,"Weineland, Arvidsson, et al., 2012","ACT-Ftf+I","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["16_A","II",16,"Weineland, Hayes, et al., 2012","ACT-Ftf+I  ","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1,"Low","Low","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns","Some concerns"]

{"sheet":"Figure (ITT)","index":3,"n_rows":1,"n_cols":13,"rows_kept":1,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Intention-to-treat","Unique ID","Study ID","Experimental","Comparator","Outcome","Weight","D1","D2","D3","D4","D5","Overall"]

{"sheet":"Figure (PP)","index":4,"n_rows":17,"n_cols":16,"rows_kept":17,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
["Per-protocol","Unique ID","Study ID","Experimental","Comparator","Outcome","Weight","D1","D2","D3","D4","D5","Overall"]
[null,"1_A",1,"ACT","BWL","Disinhibited eating behavior",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Low risk"]
[null,"2_A",2,"BT+EA","BT/BT+E","Weight loss percentage",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Some concerns"]
[null,"3_A",3,"ABT","SH","Weight loss percentage",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"High risk"]
[null,"4_A",4,"ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",1]
[null,"5_A",5,"ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"D1","Randomisation process"]
[null,"6_A",6,"ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"D2","Deviations from the intended interventions"]
[null,"7_A",7,"ACT","TAU","Weight",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"D3","Missing outcome data"]
[null,"8_A",8,"ACT-Ftf/ACT-M","C","Eating behavior",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"D4","Measurement of the outcome"]
[null,"9_A",9,"ABBI","C","Weight",1,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"D5","Selection of the reported result"]
[null,"10_A",10,"ACT-M","C","Health behaviors related to weight management",1]
[null,"11_A",11,"ACT","C","Weight-related stigma",1]
[null,"12_A",12,"ABBI","SBT","Weight",1]
[null,"13_A",13,"ACT","TAU","Weight self-stigma",1]
[null,"14_A",14,"ACT","C","Weight",1]
[null,"15_A",15,"ACT-Ftf+I","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",1]
[null,"16_A",16,"ACT-Ftf+I  ","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",1]

{"sheet":"Print (ITT)","index":5,"n_rows":0,"n_cols":0,"rows_kept":0,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}

{"sheet":"Print (PP)","index":6,"n_rows":542,"n_cols":6,"rows_kept":542,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[537,0,540,0],[537,1,537,3],[538,1,538,3],[539,1,539,3],[540,1,540,3],[541,1,541,3],[531,0,536,0],[531,1,531,3],[532,1,532,3],[533,1,533,3],[534,1,534,3],[534,5,535,5],[535,1,535,3],[536,1,536,3],[526,0,530,0],[526,1,526,3],[527,1,527,3],[528,1,528,3],[528,5,529,5],[529,1,529,3],[530,1,530,3],[519,0,525,0],[519,1,519,3],[519,5,520,5],[520,1,520,3],[521,1,521,3],[522,1,522,3],[523,1,523,3],[524,1,524,3],[525,1,525,3],[514,1,514,3],[515,0,518,0],[515,1,515,3],[515,5,516,5],[516,1,516,3],[517,1,517,3],[518,1,518,3],[503,0,506,0],[503,1,503,3],[504,1,504,3],[505,1,505,3],[506,1,506,3],[507,1,507,3],[497,0,502,0],[497,1,497,3],[498,1,498,3],[499,1,499,3],[500,1,500,3],[500,5,501,5],[501,1,501,3],[502,1,502,3],[492,0,496,0],[492,1,492,3],[493,1,493,3],[494,1,494,3],[494,5,495,5],[495,1,495,3],[496,1,496,3],[485,0,491,0],[485,1,485,3],[485,5,486,5],[486,1,486,3],[487,1,487,3],[488,1,488,3],[489,1,489,3],[490,1,490,3],[491,1,491,3],[480,1,480,3],[481,0,484,0],[481,1,481,3],[481,5,482,5],[482,1,482,3],[483,1,483,3],[484,1,484,3],[469,0,472,0],[469,1,469,3],[470,1,470,3],[471,1,471,3],[472,1,472,3],[473,1,473,3],[463,0,468,0],[463,1,463,3],[464,1,464,3],[465,1,465,3],[466,1,466,3],[466,5,467,5],[467,1,467,3],[468,1,468,3],[458,0,462,0],[458,1,458,3],[459,1,459,3],[460,1,460,3],[460,5,461,5],[461,1,461,3],[462,1,462,3],[451,0,457,0],[451,1,451,3],[451,5,452,5],[452,1,452,3],[453,1,453,3],[454,1,454,3],[455,1,455,3],[456,1,456,3],[457,1,457,3],[446,1,446,3],[447,0,450,0],[447,1,447,3],[447,5,448,5],[448,1,448,3],[449,1,449,3],[450,1,450,3],[435,0,438,0],[435,1,435,3],[436,1,436,3],[437,1,437,3],[438,1,438,3],[439,1,439,3],[429,0,434,0],[429,1,429,3],[430,1,430,3],[431,1,431,3],[432,1,432,3],[432,5,433,5],[433,1,433,3],[434,1,434,3],[424,0,428,0],[424,1,424,3],[425,1,425,3],[426,1,426,3],[426,5,427,5],[427,1,427,3],[428,1,428,3],[417,0,423,0],[417,1,417,3],[417,5,418,5],[418,1,418,3],[419,1,419,3],[420,1,420,3],[421,1,421,3],[422,1,422,3],[423,1,423,3],[412,1,412,3],[413,0,416,0],[413,1,413,3],[413,5,414,5],[414,1,414,3],[415,1,415,3],[416,1,416,3],[401,0,404,0],[401,1,401,3],[402,1,402,3],[403,1,403,3],[404,1,404,3],[405,1,405,3],[395,0,400,0],[395,1,395,3],[396,1,396,3],[397,1,397,3],[398,1,398,3],[398,5,399,5],[399,1,399,3],[400,1,400,3],[390,0,394,0],[390,1,390,3],[391,1,391,3],[392,1,392,3],[392,5,393,5],[393,1,393,3],[394,1,394,3],[383,0,389,0],[383,1,383,3],[383,5,384,5],[384,1,384,3],[385,1,385,3],[386,1,386,3],[387,1,387,3],[388,1,388,3],[389,1,389,3],[378,1,378,3],[379,0,382,0],[379,1,379,3],[379,5,380,5],[380,1,380,3],[381,1,381,3],[382,1,382,3],[367,0,370,0],[367,1,367,3],[368,1,368,3],[369,1,369,3],[370,1,370,3],[371,1,371,3],[361,0,366,0],[361,1,361,3],[362,1,362,3],[363,1,363,3],[364,1,364,3],[364,5,365,5],[365,1,365,3],[366,1,366,3],[356,0,360,0],[356,1,356,3],[357,1,357,3],[358,1,358,3],[358,5,359,5],[359,1,359,3],[360,1,360,3],[349,0,355,0],[349,1,349,3],[349,5,350,5],[350,1,350,3],[351,1,351,3],[352,1,352,3],[353,1,353,3],[354,1,354,3],[355,1,355,3],[344,1,344,3],[345,0,348,0],[345,1,345,3],[345,5,346,5],[346,1,346,3],[347,1,347,3],[348,1,348,3],[333,0,336,0],[333,1,333,3],[334,1,334,3],[335,1,335,3],[336,1,336,3],[337,1,337,3],[327,0,332,0],[327,1,327,3],[328,1,328,3],[329,1,329,3],[330,1,330,3],[330,5,331,5],[331,1,331,3],[332,1,332,3],[322,0,326,0],[322,1,322,3],[323,1,323,3],[324,1,324,3],[324,5,325,5],[325,1,325,3],[326,1,326,3],[315,0,321,0],[315,1,315,3],[315,5,316,5],[316,1,316,3],[317,1,317,3],[318,1,318,3],[319,1,319,3],[320,1,320,3],[321,1,321,3],[310,1,310,3],[311,0,314,0],[311,1,311,3],[311,5,312,5],[312,1,312,3],[313,1,313,3],[314,1,314,3],[299,0,302,0],[299,1,299,3],[300,1,300,3],[301,1,301,3],[302,1,302,3],[303,1,303,3],[293,0,298,0],[293,1,293,3],[294,1,294,3],[295,1,295,3],[296,1,296,3],[296,5,297,5],[297,1,297,3],[298,1,298,3],[288,0,292,0],[288,1,288,3],[289,1,289,3],[290,1,290,3],[290,5,291,5],[291,1,291,3],[292,1,292,3],[281,0,287,0],[281,1,281,3],[281,5,282,5],[282,1,282,3],[283,1,283,3],[284,1,284,3],[285,1,285,3],[286,1,286,3],[287,1,287,3],[276,1,276,3],[277,0,280,0],[277,1,277,3],[277,5,278,5],[278,1,278,3],[279,1,279,3],[280,1,280,3],[265,0,268,0],[265,1,265,3],[266,1,266,3],[267,1,267,3],[268,1,268,3],[269,1,269,3],[259,0,264,0],[259,1,259,3],[260,1,260,3],[261,1,261,3],[262,1,262,3],[262,5,263,5],[263,1,263,3],[264,1,264,3],[254,0,258,0],[254,1,254,3],[255,1,255,3],[256,1,256,3],[256,5,257,5],[257,1,257,3],[258,1,258,3],[247,0,253,0],[247,1,247,3],[247,5,248,5],[248,1,248,3],[249,1,249,3],[250,1,250,3],[251,1,251,3],[252,1,252,3],[253,1,253,3],[242,1,242,3],[243,0,246,0],[243,1,243,3],[243,5,244,5],[244,1,244,3],[245,1,245,3],[246,1,246,3],[231,0,234,0],[231,1,231,3],[232,1,232,3],[233,1,233,3],[234,1,234,3],[235,1,235,3],[225,0,230,0],[225,1,225,3],[226,1,226,3],[227,1,227,3],[228,1,228,3],[228,5,229,5],[229,1,229,3],[230,1,230,3],[220,0,224,0],[220,1,220,3],[221,1,221,3],[222,1,222,3],[222,5,223,5],[223,1,223,3],[224,1,224,3],[213,0,219,0],[213,1,213,3],[213,5,214,5],[214,1,214,3],[215,1,215,3],[216,1,216,3],[217,1,217,3],[218,1,218,3],[219,1,219,3],[208,1,208,3],[209,0,212,0],[209,1,209,3],[209,5,210,5],[210,1,210,3],[211,1,211,3],[212,1,212,3],[197,0,200,0],[197,1,197,3],[198,1,198,3],[199,1,199,3],[200,1,200,3],[201,1,201,3],[191,0,196,0],[191,1,191,3],[192,1,192,3],[193,1,193,3],[194,1,194,3],[194,5,195,5],[195,1,195,3],[196,1,196,3],[186,0,190,0],[186,1,186,3],[187,1,187,3],[188,1,188,3],[188,5,189,5],[189,1,189,3],[190,1,190,3],[179,0,185,0],[179,1,179,3],[179,5,180,5],[180,1,180,3],[181,1,181,3],[182,1,182,3],[183,1,183,3],[184,1,184,3],[185,1,185,3],[174,1,174,3],[175,0,178,0],[175,1,175,3],[175,5,176,5],[176,1,176,3],[177,1,177,3],[178,1,178,3],[163,0,166,0],[163,1,163,3],[164,1,164,3],[165,1,165,3],[166,1,166,3],[167,1,167,3],[157,0,162,0],[157,1,157,3],[158,1,158,3],[159,1,159,3],[160,1,160,3],[160,5,161,5],[161,1,161,3],[162,1,162,3],[152,0,156,0],[152,1,152,3],[153,1,153,3],[154,1,154,3],[154,5,155,5],[155,1,155,3],[156,1,156,3],[145,0,151,0],[145,1,145,3],[145,5,146,5],[146,1,146,3],[147,1,147,3],[148,1,148,3],[149,1,149,3],[150,1,150,3],[151,1,151,3],[140,1,140,3],[141,0,144,0],[141,1,141,3],[141,5,142,5],[142,1,142,3],[143,1,143,3],[144,1,144,3],[129,0,132,0],[129,1,129,3],[130,1,130,3],[131,1,131,3],[132,1,132,3],[133,1,133,3],[123,0,128,0],[123,1,123,3],[124,1,124,3],[125,1,125,3],[126,1,126,3],[126,5,127,5],[127,1,127,3],[128,1,128,3],[118,0,122,0],[118,1,118,3],[119,1,119,3],[120,1,120,3],[120,5,121,5],[121,1,121,3],[122,1,122,3],[111,0,117,0],[111,1,111,3],[111,5,112,5],[112,1,112,3],[113,1,113,3],[114,1,114,3],[115,1,115,3],[116,1,116,3],[117,1,117,3],[106,1,106,3],[107,0,110,0],[107,1,107,3],[107,5,108,5],[108,1,108,3],[109,1,109,3],[110,1,110,3],[95,0,98,0],[95,1,95,3],[96,1,96,3],[97,1,97,3],[98,1,98,3],[99,1,99,3],[89,0,94,0],[89,1,89,3],[90,1,90,3],[91,1,91,3],[92,1,92,3],[92,5,93,5],[93,1,93,3],[94,1,94,3],[84,0,88,0],[84,1,84,3],[85,1,85,3],[86,1,86,3],[86,5,87,5],[87,1,87,3],[88,1,88,3],[77,0,83,0],[77,1,77,3],[77,5,78,5],[78,1,78,3],[79,1,79,3],[80,1,80,3],[81,1,81,3],[82,1,82,3],[83,1,83,3],[72,1,72,3],[73,0,76,0],[73,1,73,3],[73,5,74,5],[74,1,74,3],[75,1,75,3],[76,1,76,3],[61,0,64,0],[61,1,61,3],[62,1,62,3],[63,1,63,3],[64,1,64,3],[65,1,65,3],[55,0,60,0],[55,1,55,3],[56,1,56,3],[57,1,57,3],[58,1,58,3],[58,5,59,5],[59,1,59,3],[60,1,60,3],[50,0,54,0],[50,1,50,3],[51,1,51,3],[52,1,52,3],[52,5,53,5],[53,1,53,3],[54,1,54,3],[43,0,49,0],[43,1,43,3],[43,5,44,5],[44,1,44,3],[45,1,45,3],[46,1,46,3],[47,1,47,3],[48,1,48,3],[49,1,49,3],[38,1,38,3],[39,0,42,0],[39,1,39,3],[39,5,40,5],[40,1,40,3],[41,1,41,3],[42,1,42,3],[27,0,30,0],[27,1,27,3],[28,1,28,3],[29,1,29,3],[30,1,30,3],[31,1,31,3],[21,0,26,0],[21,1,21,3],[22,1,22,3],[23,1,23,3],[24,1,24,3],[24,5,25,5],[25,1,25,3],[26,1,26,3],[16,0,20,0],[16,1,16,3],[17,1,17,3],[18,1,18,3],[18,5,19,5],[19,1,19,3],[20,1,20,3],[4,1,4,3],[5,0,8,0],[5,1,5,3],[5,5,6,5],[6,1,6,3],[7,1,7,3],[8,1,8,3],[9,0,15,0],[9,1,9,3],[9,5,10,5],[10,1,10,3],[11,1,11,3],[12,1,12,3],[13,1,13,3],[14,1,14,3],[15,1,15,3]]}
["Unique ID","1_A","Study ID",1,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Afari et al., 2019","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT","Comparator","BWL","Source"," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Disinhibited eating behavior","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","2_A","Study ID",2,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Butryn et al., 2017","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","BT+EA","Comparator","BT/BT+E","Source"," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Weight loss percentage","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","3_A","Study ID",3,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Carels et al., 2019","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ABT","Comparator","SH","Source"," Journal article(s)"]
["Outcome","Weight loss percentage","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"High"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"High"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","4_A","Study ID",4,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Forman et al., 2013","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ABBI","Comparator","SBT","Source"," Journal article(s)"]
["Outcome","Weight loss percentage","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","5_A","Study ID",5,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Forman et al., 2016","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ABBI","Comparator","SBT","Source"," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Weight loss percentage","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","6_A","Study ID",6,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Forman et al., 2019","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ABBI","Comparator","SBT","Source"," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Weight loss percentage","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","7_A","Study ID",7,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Frayn et al., 2020","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT","Comparator","TAU","Source"," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Weight","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"High"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"High"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"High"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","8_A","Study ID",8,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Järvelä-Reijonen et al., 2018","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT-Ftf/ACT-M","Comparator","C","Source"," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Eating behavior","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","9_A","Study ID",9,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Katterman et al., 2014","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ABBI","Comparator","C","Source"," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)"]
["Outcome","Weight","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","10_A","Study ID",10,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Levin et al., 2017","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT-M","Comparator","C","Source"," Journal article(s)"]
["Outcome","Health behaviors related to weight management","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","11_A","Study ID",11,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Lillis et al., 2009","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT","Comparator","C","Source"," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)"]
["Outcome","Weight-related stigma","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","12_A","Study ID",12,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Lillis et al., 2016","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ABBI","Comparator","SBT","Source"," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)"]
["Outcome","Weight","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","13_A","Study ID",13,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Palmeira et al., 2017","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT","Comparator","TAU","Source"," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)"]
["Outcome","Weight self-stigma","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","14_A","Study ID",14,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Tapper et al., 2009","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT","Comparator","C","Source"," Journal article(s)"]
["Outcome","Weight","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","15_A","Study ID",15,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Weineland, Arvidsson, et al., 2012","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT-Ftf+I","Comparator","TAU","Source"," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)"]
["Outcome","Body dissatisfaction","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
[]
[]
["Unique ID","16_A","Study ID",16,"Assessor","II"]
["Ref or Label","Weineland, Hayes, et al., 2012","Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["Experimental","ACT-Ftf+I  ","Comparator","TAU","Source"," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)"]
["Outcome","Body dissatisfaction","Results",null,"Weight",1]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,null,"Y"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?",null,null,"NA"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Low"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?",null,null,"N"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,null,"PY"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,"NI"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,"PN"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement",null,null,"Some concerns"]

{"sheet":"Check","index":7,"n_rows":18,"n_cols":85,"rows_kept":18,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[0,80,0,83],[0,0,0,12],[0,13,0,22],[0,23,0,40],[0,41,0,53],[0,54,0,68],[0,69,0,79]]}
["Basic information",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 1. Randomization process",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 2. Deviations from intended interventions",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 3. Mising outcome data",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 4. Measurement of the outcome",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 5. Selection of the reported result",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Domain 6. Overall Bias"]
["Time","Unique ID","Assessor","Study ID","Reference","Experimental","Comparator","Outcome","Results","Aim","Effect of adhering to intervention?","Weight","Sources","1.1","1.2","Note for 1.1&1.2","1.3","Note for 1.3","1.0 Algorithm result","1.0 Assessor's Judgement","1.0 General note","1.0 Optional Question","1.0 Note for optional question","2.1","2.2","Note for 2.1&2.2","2.3","Note for 2.3","2.4","Note for 2.4","2.5","Note for 2.5","2.6","Note for 2.6","2.7","Note for 2.7","2.0 Algorithm result","2.0 Assessor's Judgement","2.0 General Notes","2.0 Optional Question","2.0 Note for optional question","3.1","Note for 3.1","3.2","Note for 3.2","3.3","Note for 3.3&3.4","3.4","Note for 3.4 (not use)","3.0 Algorithm result","3.0 Assessor's judgement","3.0 Gerenal notes","3.0 Optional Question","3.0 Note for optional question","4.1","Note for 4.1","4.2","Note for 4.2","4.3","Note for 4.3","4.4","Note for 4.4&4.5","4.5","Note for 4.5 (not use)","4.0 Algorithm result","4.0 Assessor's Judgement","4.0 General note","4.0 Optional Question","4.0 Note for optional question","5.1","Note for 5.1","5.2","Note for 5.2","5.3","Note for 5.3","5.0 Algorithm result","5.0 Assessor's Judgement","5.0 General note","5.0 Optional Question","5.0 Note for optional question","Algorithm's overall Judgement","Assessor's overall Judgement","6.0 General Note","6.0 Optional Question","6.0 Note for optional question"]
["2020/07/03 16.05","1_A","EM",1,"Afari et al., 2019","ACT","BWL","Disinhibited eating behavior",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","N",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Low","Low"]
["2020/07/03 16.57","2_A","EM",2,"Butryn et al., 2017","BT+EA","BT/BT+E","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/03 17.33","3_A","EM",3,"Carels et al., 2019","ABT","SH","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","Y",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PY",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PY",null,"High","High",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"NI",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"High","High"]
["2020/07/06 11.24","4_A","EM",4,"Forman et al., 2013","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","Y",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"NI",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/06 12.16","5_A","EM",5,"Forman et al., 2016","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","Y",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/06 12.49","6_A","EM",6,"Forman et al., 2019","ABBI","SBT","Weight loss percentage",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","Y",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/06 13.21","7_A","EM",7,"Frayn et al., 2020","ACT","TAU","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,null,null,"High","High",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PY",null,"High","High",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"High","High"]
["2020/07/08 12.02","8_A","EM",8,"Järvelä-Reijonen et al., 2018","ACT-Ftf/ACT-M","C","Eating behavior",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/08 12.47","9_A","EM",9,"Katterman et al., 2014","ABBI","C","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"PY",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/08 13.26","10_A","EM",10,"Levin et al., 2017","ACT-M","C","Health behaviors related to weight management",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","Y",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/08 14.05","11_A","EM",11,"Lillis et al., 2009","ACT","C","Weight-related stigma",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/08 16.45","12_A","EM",12,"Lillis et al., 2016","ABBI","SBT","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Trial protocol; Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/09 08.11","13_A","EM",13,"Palmeira et al., 2017","ACT","TAU","Weight self-stigma",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/09 08.47","14_A","EM",14,"Tapper et al., 2009","ACT","C","Weight",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s)","Y","PY",null,"NI",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"N",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"N",null,"NA",null,"NA",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/09 09.32","15_A","EM",15,"Weineland, Arvidsson, et al., 2012","ACT-Ftf+I","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]
["2020/07/09 11.04","16_A","EM",16,"Weineland, Hayes, et al., 2012","ACT-Ftf+I  ","TAU","Body dissatisfaction",null,"adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)"," occurance of non-protocol interventions; failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome; non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants",1," Journal article(s); “Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Y","PY",null,"N",null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"Y","Y",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"NA",null,null,null,"Low","Low",null,null,null,"N",null,"N",null,"Y",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"PN",null,"N",null,"PY",null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"NI",null,"PN",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","Some concerns",null,null,null,"Some concerns","Some concerns"]

{"sheet":"Print_format (PP)","index":8,"n_rows":32,"n_cols":6,"rows_kept":32,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[18,5,19,5],[24,5,25,5],[4,1,4,3],[5,0,8,0],[5,1,5,3],[5,5,6,5],[6,1,6,3],[7,1,7,3],[8,1,8,3],[9,5,10,5],[10,1,10,3],[11,1,11,3],[12,1,12,3],[13,1,13,3],[9,0,15,0],[9,1,9,3],[14,1,14,3],[15,1,15,3],[16,0,20,0],[16,1,16,3],[17,1,17,3],[18,1,18,3],[20,1,20,3],[19,1,19,3],[31,1,31,3],[21,0,26,0],[21,1,21,3],[22,1,22,3],[26,1,26,3],[23,1,23,3],[25,1,25,3],[24,1,24,3],[29,1,29,3],[27,0,30,0],[27,1,27,3],[28,1,28,3],[30,1,30,3]]}
["Unique ID",null,"Study ID",null,"Assessor"]
["Ref or Label",null,"Aim","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","The effect of adhering to intervention…"]
["Experimental",null,"Comparator",null,"Source"]
["Outcome",null,"Results",null,"Weight"]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?"]
[null,"2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?"]
[null,"2.3. [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important non-protocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?"]
[null,"2.4. [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?"]
[null,"2.5. [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?"]
[null,"2.6. If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement"]

{"sheet":"Print_format (ITT)","index":9,"n_rows":33,"n_cols":6,"rows_kept":33,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[19,5,20,5],[25,5,26,5],[5,0,8,0],[5,1,5,3],[5,5,6,5],[6,1,6,3],[7,1,7,3],[8,1,8,3],[9,5,10,5],[10,1,10,3],[11,1,11,3],[12,1,12,3],[20,1,20,3],[17,0,21,0],[17,1,17,3],[18,1,18,3],[4,1,4,3],[9,0,16,0],[9,1,9,3],[13,1,13,3],[14,1,14,3],[16,1,16,3],[15,1,15,3],[19,1,19,3],[21,1,21,3],[32,1,32,3],[22,0,27,0],[22,1,22,3],[23,1,23,3],[27,1,27,3],[24,1,24,3],[25,1,25,3],[26,1,26,3],[30,1,30,3],[28,0,31,0],[28,1,28,3],[29,1,29,3],[31,1,31,3]]}
["Unique ID",null,"Study ID",null,"Assessor"]
["Ref or Label",null,"Aim","assignment to intervention (the 'intention-to-treat' effect)\n\n"]
["Experimental",null,"Comparator",null,"Source"]
["Outcome",null,"Results",null,"Weight"]
["Domain","Signalling question",null,null,"Response","Comments"]
["Bias arising from the randomization process","1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?"]
[null,"1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?"]
[null,"1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias due to deviations from intended interventions","2.1.Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?"]
[null,"2.2.Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?"]
[null,"2.3. If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were there deviations from the intended intervention that arose because of the experimental context?"]
[null,"2.4 If Y/PY to 2.3: Were these deviations likely to have affected the outcome?"]
[null,"2.5. If Y/PY/NI to 2.4: Were these deviations from intended intervention balanced between groups?"]
[null,"2.6 Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of assignment to intervention?"]
[null,"2.7 If N/PN/NI to 2.6: Was there potential for a substantial impact (on the result) of the failure to analyse participants in the group to which they were randomized?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias due to missing outcome data","3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?"]
[null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that result was not biased by missing outcome data?"]
[null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?"]
[null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias in measurement of the outcome","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?"]
[null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?"]
[null,"4.3 Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?"]
[null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?"]
[null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Bias in selection of the reported result","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?"]
[null,"5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?"]
[null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?"]
[null,"Risk of bias judgement"]
["Overall bias","Risk of bias judgement"]

{"sheet":"Function Tab","index":10,"n_rows":12,"n_cols":19,"rows_kept":12,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
[null,"Journal article(s)","NA","Yes",null,"1.1 Was the allocation sequence random?",null,"2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?","2.1 Were participants aware of their assigned intervention during the trial?",null,"3.1 Were data for this outcome available for all, or nearly all, participants randomized?","Individually Randomized, Parallel Group Trials","4.1 Was the method of measuring the outcome inappropriate?","assignment to intervention (the 'intention-to-treat' effect)","5.1 Were the data that produced this result analysed in accordance with a pre-specified analysis plan that was finalized before unblinded outcome data were available for analysis?",null,null,null,"occurance of non-protocol interventions"]
["NA","Trial protocol","Favours experimental ","No (Please include reasons in the note)","Y","1.2 Was the allocation sequence concealed until participants were enrolled and assigned to interventions?","Low","2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?","2.2 Were carers and people delivering the interventions aware of participants' assigned intervention during the trial?",null,"3.2 If N/PN/NI to 3.1: Is there evidence that the result was not biased by missing outcome data?",null,"4.2 Could measurement or ascertainment of the outcome have differed between intervention groups?","adhering to intervention (the 'per-protocol' effect)","5.2 ... multiple eligible outcome measurements (e.g. scales, definitions, time points) within the outcome domain?",null,null,null,"failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome"]
["Y","Statistical analysis plan (SAP)","Favours comparator ",null,"PY","1.3 Did baseline differences between intervention groups suggest a problem with the randomization process?","High","2.3 [If applicable:] If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were important nonprotocol interventions balanced across intervention groups?","2.3 If Y/PY/NI to 2.1 or 2.2: Were there deviations from the intended intervention that arose because of the trial context?",null,"3.3 If N/PN to 3.2: Could missingness in the outcome depend on its true value?",null,"4.3 If N/PN/NI to 4.1 and 4.2: Were outcome assessors aware of the intervention received by study participants?",null,"5.3 ... multiple eligible analyses of the data?",null,null,null,"non-adherence to their assigned intervention by trial participants"]
["PY","Non-commercial trial registry record (e.g. ClinicalTrials.gov record)","Towards null ",null,"PN",null,"Some concerns","2.4 [If applicable:] Were there failures in implementing the intervention that could have affected the outcome?","2.4 If Y/PY to 2.3: Were these deviations likely to have affected the outcome?",null,"3.4 If Y/PY/NI to 3.3: Is it likely that missingness in the outcome depended on its true value?",null,"4.4 If Y/PY/NI to 4.3: Could assessment of the outcome have been influenced by knowledge of intervention received?"]
["PN","Company-owned trial registry record (e.g. GSK Clinical Study Register record)","Away from null ",null,"N",null,null,"2.5 [If applicable:] Was there non-adherence to the assigned intervention regimen that could have affected participants’ outcomes?","2.5. If Y/PY/NI to 2.4: Were these deviations from intended intervention balanced between groups?",null,null,null,"4.5 If Y/PY/NI to 4.4: Is it likely that assessment of the outcome was influenced by knowledge of intervention received?"]
["N","“Grey literature” (e.g. unpublished thesis)","Unpredictable",null,"NI",null,null,"2.6 If N/PN/NI to 2.3, or Y/PY/NI to 2.4 or 2.5: Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of adhering to the intervention?","2.6 Was an appropriate analysis used to estimate the effect of assignment to intervention?"]
["NI","Conference abstract(s) about the trial",null,null,null,null,null,null,"2.7 If N/PN/NI to 2.6: Was there potential for a substantial impact (on the result) of the failure to analyse participants in the group to which they were randomized?"]
[null,"Regulatory document (e.g. Clinical Study Report, Drug Approval Package)"]
[null,"Research ethics application"]
[null,"Grant database summary (e.g. NIH RePORTER, Research Councils UK Gateway to Research)"]
[null,"Personal communication with trialist"]
[null,"Personal communication with the sponsor"]